Best Rated Dog Treats: Pur Luv Chicken Wins

The best rated dog treats in this round-up are Pur Luv Chicken Jerky Dog Treats, a 1 lb bag of jerky whose first ingredient is real chicken breast and whose format keeps a chewer busy longer than a biscuit. Most treat guides argue about grain versus grain-free. That is not what decides it. The deciding split is format, because a jerky strip, a soft chew, a hard biscuit and a freeze-dried liver cube do four different jobs. For pure training, Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Beef Liver is the sharper tool.

Best rated dog treats at a glance

What most buyers get wrong about treat labels

The label most owners read first is the front. It says things like "real chicken", "natural", "wholesome". None of those words is regulated the way you probably think. The panel that actually tells you something is the ingredient list on the back, in order by weight.

Here is what to do with it. Read the first three ingredients. If a named protein is not among them, the bag is mostly starch and flavouring. Then scan for the exclusions that matter for your dog: corn, wheat, soy, added colours, artificial preservatives.

• Blue Buffalo Health Bars are described as free from corn, wheat, soy, and artificial colours or BHA.
• Full Moon Essential Beef Savory Sticks are described as free from glycerin, grains, corn, wheat, and soy.
• Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Beef Liver is described as single-ingredient: 100% beef liver.
• Pur Luv Chicken Jerky is described as having no artificial flavours, colours, or preservatives.

Those are the four bags here whose ingredient stories are the tightest. That is a genuine differentiator inside this set, and it is the kind of claim you can check on the listing itself in a second tab.

How I narrowed seven bags down to a ranked set

I compared the published specifications side by side, then weighted them against what a treat actually has to do in a normal household. The criteria came in this order.

1. Ingredient discipline. Named animal protein first, no filler-heavy carriers, no artificial colours or preservatives. This carried the most weight because it is checkable on the listing.
2. Format fit for job. Training, everyday reward, chew satisfaction and long-lasting occupation are four jobs. A treat that does one well beats a treat that does all four poorly.
3. Bag economics. Weight per bag, from 2.1 oz up to 2.5 lb. A tiny bag of high-value trainer is not competing with a 40 oz canister of biscuits, and I ranked them for their own job.
4. Set popularity signal. Sales rank inside the treats category, treated as a tiebreaker rather than a headline. Blue Buffalo Health Bars and Pur Luv Chicken Jerky sit near the top of this set on that measure.
5. Category placement. The rawhide entry sits in a different sub-category from the biscuits, and I named it as the chew rather than the everyday snack for that reason.

Everything below survived all five checks. The order reflects how often I would reach for the bag in an average week.

1. Pur Luv Chicken Jerky Dog Treats — Best overall

A 1 lb bag of jerky whose first ingredient is real chicken breast, in a format that keeps a chewer working longer than any biscuit here.

Best for: medium and large dogs who need a satisfying chew Skip it if: you want tiny training bites

Within this set, the Pur Luv bag is the only true jerky. That matters because jerky occupies a middle ground the other formats do not fill. A biscuit is gone in a bite. A rawhide kabob can be a twenty-minute project. A jerky strip sits in between: long enough to feel like a reward, short enough to hand out more than one in a session. Pur Luv says chicken is the first ingredient, that the deck is a limited one, and that the recipe carries no artificial flavours, colours or preservatives. The bag weighs 1 lb, packaged at 10.2 x 3.35 x 8.07 in, model 84715. It sells faster than most of this set inside its jerky sub-category, which is the closest thing to a popularity signal the data supports.

The trade-off is portion size. A jerky strip is not a small trainer cube, so you will still want a second bag for clicker work. Compared with the freeze-dried liver bag, this one costs more per session but lasts longer per piece.

Pros:

• Real chicken listed as the first ingredient
• Jerky format lasts longer than biscuits in this set
• No artificial flavours, colours or preservatives, per the listing
• 1 lb bag, one of the larger high-protein options here
• Only jerky pick in the round-up

Cons:

• Strips are too big for rapid-fire training
• Priced above the biscuit picks in this set
• Only two sellers currently list it

2. Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Dog Treats — Best upgrade

A 2.1 oz bag of single-ingredient beef liver, bite-sized and shelf stable, built for high-value training rewards.

Best for: trainers who need a tiny, high-value reward Skip it if: you need a treat that lasts more than one bite

This is the only freeze-dried pick in the round-up and the only single-ingredient one: Vital Essentials says the bag contains 100% beef liver with no fillers, preservatives, artificial flavours or colours. The bag is small at 2.1 oz, dimensions 9.25 x 2.5 x 5.75 in, released in 2023. Freeze-drying preserves the smell, which is why a dog that ignores biscuits in a busy park will still turn its head for one of these cubes. That is the whole reason a trainer buys them.

The economics are different from every other bag here. Two ounces goes fast if you use liver as your everyday snack, so the right way to think about this bag is as a specialist tool. Reserve it for recall practice, vet visits, thunderstorms and anywhere else you need the strongest reward in the pouch. Against the Milk-Bone MaroSnacks canister, which is 2.5 lb of biscuits for casual use, this bag makes the opposite trade: less quantity, far more attention per piece.

Pros:

• Single ingredient, 100% beef liver per the listing
• Bite-sized pieces suit training routines
• No fillers, preservatives, artificial flavours or colours
• Shelf stable and easy to carry
• Only freeze-dried option in this set

Cons:

• Smallest bag in the round-up at 2.1 oz
• Not a chew, gone in a bite
• Runs through fast in daily use

3. Blue Buffalo Health Bars Bacon Egg & Cheese Dog Biscuits — Best budget pick

A crunchy 16 oz biscuit bag with a bacon, egg and cheese recipe and a clean exclusion list, at the cheapest price position in the set.

Best for: big dogs who inhale biscuits by the handful Skip it if: your dog cannot tolerate eggs or dairy

Blue Buffalo is the cheapest of the seven and the one buyers reach for most often inside this set on the sales-rank signal. The bag is 1.1 lb at 2.5 x 11 x 8.13 in, and Blue Buffalo describes the biscuits as free from chicken by-product meals, corn, wheat, soy, and artificial preservatives like BHA. That combination is unusual at the entry price position: most cheap biscuits carry at least one of those. The recipe leans on oatmeal, bacon and egg, which is why the aroma coming out of a fresh bag is closer to breakfast than kibble.

The catch is the recipe itself. If your dog has a known sensitivity to eggs or dairy, this is not the biscuit for you. And a hard oven-baked bar suits an adult dog with a strong jaw better than a senior with worn teeth, which is where the Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy canister below picks up the slack. As a default biscuit for a healthy adult dog, though, this is the easiest recommendation on the list.

Pros:

• Cheapest position in the set
• Free from corn, wheat and soy per the listing
• No BHA or artificial colours, per Blue Buffalo
• Named protein and dairy ingredients in the recipe
• Sells faster than most picks here on set sales rank

Cons:

• Egg and cheese rule it out for some sensitivities
• Hard biscuit is wrong for older or dental-issue dogs
• 1.1 lb bag runs out quickly with a large dog

4. Milk-Bone MaroSnacks Small Dog Treats with Real Bone Marrow — Most versatile

A 40 oz canister of small biscuits at 10 calories each, per the listing, that doubles as a training treat and everyday snack.

Best for: training sessions plus everyday snacks in one canister Skip it if: you want soft, gummable treats

The MaroSnacks canister is the heaviest bag in the round-up at 2.5 lb, dimensions 8.1 x 5.8 x 5.8 in, and it is also the only pick here with a warranty line on the listing (as labelled). Milk-Bone describes the biscuits as 10 calories each, crunchy outside and meaty inside, made with calcium. Ten calories is the number that matters, because it is low enough that you can hand out several during a training session without wrecking a daily calorie budget. That is the specific advantage a "training-only" treat rarely has.

Versatile does not mean best in class. The recipe is not as tight as Full Moon's or Vital Essentials's, and the biscuit format is not chewy for a senior dog. Against Blue Buffalo Health Bars, MaroSnacks is a smaller, lower-calorie biscuit in a bigger canister, so the trade you are making is quantity and calorie control against a slightly less strict ingredient story. For a mixed household that wants one canister on the shelf, this is the honest all-rounder.

Pros:

• 10 calories per biscuit, per the listing
• 2.5 lb canister, largest bag in the set
• Small size suits training and everyday use
• Made with calcium, per Milk-Bone
• Warranty line on the listing

Cons:

• Not soft enough for older dogs with dental issues
• Ingredient panel less strict than Full Moon
• No published price band in this data set

5. Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy Dog Treats — Best compact

A 25 oz canister of soft, chewy treats made with real beef and filet mignon, per the listing, sized right for dogs that struggle with hard biscuits.

Best for: senior dogs or puppies who struggle with hard biscuits Skip it if: your dog needs a longer chew

Soft treats do a job hard biscuits cannot. Puppies still growing teeth, seniors with worn molars, dogs recovering from dental work: all of them want a reward they can gum rather than crack. This canister is the only true soft-and-chewy option in the set. Milk-Bone describes the recipe as containing real beef and filet mignon, 18% protein, with 12 vitamins and minerals including iron, zinc and B12. The canister weighs 1.56 lb.

The trade-off is chew time. Soft means quick, so a dog looking for a real chew will finish one in seconds and ask for another. It is also less exacting on ingredients than the Full Moon savory sticks below, which sit at a higher price position but publish a stricter recipe. Choose this canister for the format, not the ingredient story: it is the answer to "my dog cannot chew hard biscuits any more", and it is the only bag here that answers that question directly.

Pros:

• Only soft-and-chewy option in this set
• 18% protein claim, plus 12 vitamins and minerals
• 25 oz canister keeps well on the shelf
• Suits dogs of all ages and jaw strengths
• Real beef and filet mignon listed in the recipe

Cons:

• Not a chew, disappears in a bite or two
• Ingredient panel less strict than Full Moon or Vital Essentials
• Not ideal for dental cleaning

6. Full Moon All Natural Human Grade Dog Treats — Best for families

A 22 oz bag of beef savory sticks Full Moon describes as human-grade, made with free-range beef and free from glycerin, grains, corn, wheat and soy.

Best for: households that read every ingredient panel Skip it if: you feed a poultry-only diet

Full Moon makes the strongest ingredient claim in the set. The company says these sticks meet USDA standards fit for human consumption, use free-range beef from family farms, and skip glycerin, grains, corn, wheat and soy. That is a fuller exclusion list than any biscuit here, and the shape, meat sticks at 1.38 lb per bag, sits between a jerky strip and a soft chew. For a household that reads every panel and wants a single treat everyone in the family is comfortable feeding, this is the pick.

The obvious limit is protein source. It is beef-only, so a dog on a poultry-based rotation, or one avoiding beef for medical reasons, is out. Compared with the Pur Luv chicken jerky at the top of the list, Full Moon carries the tighter ingredient story but the smaller bag and the higher price position. The trade you are making is bag size against label discipline, and for families the label often wins.

Pros:

• Human-grade claim per Full Moon
• Free from glycerin, grains, corn, wheat and soy
• USDA-approved free range beef, per the listing
• Meat-stick format works for a range of dog sizes
• Made in the United States

Cons:

• Beef-only, no protein rotation from this bag
• Priced at the premium position in the set
• 1.38 lb bag is smaller than the biscuit canisters here

7. Good 'n' Fun Kabobs — Best premium

A 24 oz bag of kabob-shaped beef hide chews wrapped in real chicken, built as a long-lasting occupier rather than an everyday snack.

Best for: power chewers who finish a biscuit in seconds Skip it if: you avoid rawhide entirely

Kabobs sit in the rawhide sub-category, and that placement tells you the job. Good 'n' Fun describes the chews as premium beef hide wrapped with real chicken, with pork hide, duck and chicken liver in the recipe, and says the natural chewing action helps reduce tartar and remove plaque. The bag weighs 1.5 lb at 10 x 9.45 x 3.5 in. This is the treat you hand a bored dog before a long call, not one you use as a training reward.

Rawhide is polarising, and for good reason. Some vets and owners avoid it entirely because of choking and blockage risks with aggressive chewers, so this is a supervised treat and not a leave-them-to-it treat. Against every other bag on this list, Kabobs are the only pick that lasts more than a few minutes per piece, and that is the whole case for buying them. If rawhide is a hard no in your house, take Pur Luv jerky instead.

Pros:

• Only long-lasting chew in this round-up
• Multi-protein recipe wrapped in real chicken
• Chewing action described as helping reduce tartar
• Kabob shape holds a dog's attention longer than strips
• 1.5 lb bag lasts across multiple sessions

Cons:

• Rawhide is not suitable for every household
• Priced at the top of the set
• Needs supervision with aggressive chewers

Chewy, crunchy, jerky or freeze-dried: which format for which dog?

Format is the first fork in the road, and it decides more than flavour does. Here is how the seven bags split.

• Jerky (Pur Luv Chicken Jerky): a strip that takes a real minute to work through. Good for medium and large dogs, better for reward than for rapid-fire training.
• Freeze-dried (Vital Essentials Beef Liver): a bite-sized cube with a strong aroma. The high-value trainer, best used sparingly.
• Hard biscuit (Blue Buffalo Health Bars, Milk-Bone MaroSnacks): the everyday workhorse. Best for healthy adult dogs with strong jaws.
• Soft chew (Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy): the answer for seniors, puppies and dental-recovery dogs. Not a chew, a gum.
• Meat stick (Full Moon Beef Savory Sticks): the middle ground, cleaner ingredient story than a biscuit, quicker than jerky.
• Rawhide kabob (Good 'n' Fun Kabobs): the long-occupier. Supervised only.

The right household usually keeps two bags on the shelf: one biscuit or meat stick for casual rewards, and one specialist bag, freeze-dried liver or a rawhide kabob, for the moments the everyday treat cannot handle.

How long does a bag actually last?

Bag size and treat size interact. A 2.5 lb canister of small biscuits at 10 calories each is a very different lifetime than a 2.1 oz bag of freeze-dried liver, even though both look like "a bag of treats" on the listing.

For a rough sense of it, use this order. The Milk-Bone MaroSnacks canister at 2.5 lb is the longest-lasting bag here for everyday rewards, followed by Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy at 1.56 lb and Good 'n' Fun Kabobs at 1.5 lb. Pur Luv sits at 1 lb of jerky strips, Full Moon at 1.38 lb of meat sticks, Blue Buffalo at 1.1 lb of biscuits, and Vital Essentials at 2.1 oz. The freeze-dried bag looks small because it is small, and that is the point: it is not built to be the everyday bag.

Two practical rules help. Treats should stay under about 10% of your dog's daily calories, which is why the 10-calorie MaroSnacks biscuit is a genuinely useful figure. And a resealable bag or a canister keeps aroma in, which matters more for jerky and freeze-dried picks than for hard biscuits.

What to check on the ingredient panel

Before you add a bag to the cart, run this quick pass on the panel. It takes under a minute and rules out most of the bags you do not want.

1. First three ingredients. A named protein, ideally the same one on the front of the bag, should be there. Pur Luv says chicken is first; Vital Essentials says beef liver is the only ingredient.
2. Excluded fillers. Look for the words "no corn, wheat, or soy" or the specific ingredient names in the list. Blue Buffalo and Full Moon both publish this exclusion.
3. Artificial colours and preservatives. Both Pur Luv and Blue Buffalo describe their recipes as free from these.
4. Protein source variety. If you rotate proteins across meals, match the treat too. Full Moon is beef-only, Pur Luv is chicken-only, Good 'n' Fun uses beef, pork, duck and chicken.
5. Format and calories. Match the treat size to the job. A 10-calorie biscuit fits a training session; a jerky strip does not.

If a bag fails any of the first three checks, put it back on the shelf. The other treats here all pass at least three of the five, and the winner passes all five.

How do these picks compare on training use?

Training treats have to be small, aromatic and forgettable enough that your dog will take twenty in a row. Two picks in this set are built for it, and one is nearly there.

Vital Essentials Beef Liver is the sharpest training tool. Single ingredient, strong aroma, bite-sized, per the listing. Use it for recall, distraction work, and vet visits. Milk-Bone MaroSnacks is the everyday training biscuit: 10 calories per piece and a full 2.5 lb canister to work through. Blue Buffalo Health Bars can be broken into smaller pieces for training but the biscuit is designed as a whole reward, so you will lose some to crumbs. Pur Luv, Full Moon, Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy and the Kabobs are rewards, not trainers.

The verdict

Pur Luv Chicken Jerky Dog Treats wins the round-up. It is the only true jerky here, its recipe leads with real chicken breast, and its 1 lb bag hits the middle of the set on size while landing high on the popularity signal inside its jerky sub-category. For a household with one medium or large dog and a normal treat routine, it is the right default.

Two conditions flip that recommendation. If your primary use is training, Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Beef Liver is the sharper tool: single ingredient, bite-sized, strong aroma. Buy that bag first and keep Pur Luv on the shelf for rewards outside training. If your dog is a power chewer who finishes a biscuit in seconds and rawhide is acceptable in your household, Good 'n' Fun Kabobs is the only long-lasting occupier in this list, and it is the right buy for that job. For a senior or puppy who struggles with hard biscuits, Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy is the format answer regardless of what the ingredient panel says about the rest of the list.

FAQ

Which of these best rated dog treats is the healthiest option?

Which of these ranks as the healthiest depends on how you weight the ingredient panel against the format. Full Moon Essential Beef Savory Sticks publish the tightest exclusion list here, describing the recipe as free from glycerin, grains, corn, wheat and soy, with a human-grade claim. Vital Essentials is the only single-ingredient bag, 100% beef liver. Between the two, Full Moon is the everyday choice and Vital Essentials the specialist reward.

Is Pur Luv Chicken Jerky worth it over a cheaper biscuit?

Is Pur Luv Chicken Jerky worth choosing over a cheaper biscuit? For most medium and large dogs, yes. The 1 lb bag lists chicken as the first ingredient, carries no artificial flavours, colours or preservatives per the listing, and delivers a jerky format that no biscuit in this set matches. If your dog is small, senior, or on a strict training routine, a biscuit or a freeze-dried cube fits the job better.

How does the 2.5 lb Milk-Bone MaroSnacks canister compare to Blue Buffalo Health Bars?

How does the MaroSnacks canister compare with Blue Buffalo Health Bars? MaroSnacks is bigger at 2.5 lb versus 1.1 lb, and the pieces are 10 calories each per the listing, which suits training use. Blue Buffalo is the cheaper bag and publishes the stricter ingredient story: no corn, wheat or soy, no BHA or artificial colours. Pick MaroSnacks for volume and calorie control, Blue Buffalo for the recipe.

Are Good 'n' Fun Kabobs safe for aggressive chewers?

Are Good 'n' Fun Kabobs safe for an aggressive chewer? They sit in the rawhide category, which means they should always be supervised, and they are not the right choice for every household. Good 'n' Fun describes the kabobs as premium beef hide wrapped in real chicken, with a chewing action that helps reduce tartar. If you avoid rawhide entirely, choose Pur Luv jerky as the closest long-reward alternative instead.

What is the best rated dog treats pick for training a new puppy?

What is the best pick for training a new puppy? Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Beef Liver is the sharpest tool for the job in this set: bite-sized, single-ingredient, strong aroma, and shelf stable per the listing. Milk-Bone MaroSnacks is the affordable everyday backup at 10 calories per piece. Keep the liver bag for high-distraction moments like recall practice and the MaroSnacks canister for the easy wins at home.

Take one bag off this list this week rather than three. If you have never bought jerky treats before, start with Pur Luv and see how your dog responds to the format compared with the biscuits currently on your shelf. If you already know biscuits are the right shape for your household and you want a cleaner recipe, Blue Buffalo Health Bars is the low-risk swap. And if you have a training goal on the calendar, a puppy class, a recall you want to fix, a vet visit that never goes well, buy the Vital Essentials liver bag now and keep it in the pouch. Small bag, sharp tool, quiet confidence.

Last updated: September 9, 2026. Product availability re-checked.

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.